Anti-Chinese racism, nationalism and state formation in post-revolutionary Mexico, 1920s–1930s

Anti-Chinese racism, nationalism and state formation in post-revolutionary Mexico, 1920s–1930s
of 64
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
  1 Political Power and Social Theory. Vol. 14 (2000): 91-140.  Race, Mestizaje and NationalismSonora’s Anti-Chinese Movement and State FormationIn Post-revolutionary M!ico Gerardo Rénique Associate Professor  Department of History of theCity College of the City of New Yor    A"S#RAC# !his article e"amines the mostly neglected anti#Chinese mo$ement that% supported &y  'e"ico(s official post#re$olutionary party% persecuted and finally e"pelled a large ma)ority of 'e"ico(s Chinese community* !he article analy+es the tra)ectory of this racial mo$ement from its srcins as a social and political mo$ement to its incorporation within the new orthodo"y of the post#re$olutionary state* ,n particular% it e"amines the rele$ance of anti#Chinese racism and ideology for the resolution of the hegemonic  struggle &etween the two dominant -onoran caudillos  Plutarco .lias Calles and Al$aro /&reg0n* -econdly% it considers the importance of anti#Chinese ideology and actions for the creation of consent in the 1unsta&le equili&rium2 that shaped 'e"ican politics &etween 3456 and 3478* 9inally% this article e"amines the epistemological compati&ility &etween the anti#Chinese ideology% the 1cultural re$olution2 of 'e"ico(s post#re$olutionary regimes and the racial understandings and sentiments of the mestia!e  theories informing 'e"ican re$olutionary nationalism* !he article suggests that a reconsideration of race offers a &etter theoretical understanding of 'e"ican state  formation and the cultural processes through which social identities tae form in interaction with the state% its institutions and discourses* !he treatment of race as a  political pro&lem also contri&utes to a &etter understanding of the mechanisms and  processes that transform diffuse racial sentiments% perceptions and e"pectations into militant and politically organi+ed racial mo$ements* Introduction "n the 19#0s$ a racial mo%ement s&onsored and su&&orted 'y eico*s o++icial  &ost-re%olutionary &arty &ersecuted and$ +inally$ e&elled a lar,e ma!ority o+ eicos hinese community. /lthou,h thorou,hly documented 'y state institutions at the time$ as well as in the a'undant literature ,enerated 'y the anti-hinese mo%ement itsel+$ the tra,ic e%ents leadin, u& to this e&ulsion ha%e recei%ed scant attention in the literature on eicos &ost-re%olutionary &eriod. ne e&lanation +or this ne,lect is su,,ested 'y  2 e++rey oulds com&ellin, analysis o+ the ideolo,ical wei,ht o+ mestia!e or the idea o+ racial and cultural miture in entral /merican national &ro!ects. Ta3in, icara,ua as a case study ould demonstrates how the myth o+ mestia!e has ser%ed to eliminate indi,enous history and culture +rom 'oth intellectual accounts --includin, those associated with the Sandinista re,ime5and indi,enous historical memory (ould$ 1996). oncei%ed and &o&ularied 'y 7atin /merican intellectual and &olitical elites as a means to di++erentiate 7atin /merican society +rom the 8racial dictatorshi& o+ the nited States mestia!e --li3e the 8mulattoiation es&oused 'y the ;railian and u'an elites5is widely ima,ined as the +oundation o+ a 7atin /merican 8racial democracy which is (su&&osedly) +ree o+ the sti,ma o+ 'oth race and racial discrimination. 1  <or the case o+ eico$ =ni,ht and others ha%e ar,ued that mestia!e was the %ehicle 'y which 7atin /merican elites ha%e en%isioned a &olitical community o+ culturally and racially homo,eneous indi%iduals that is &rescri'ed 'y modern notions o+ the li'eral nation-state (/. =ni,ht$ 1990). /lon, with ould and =ni,ht$ " a&&roach mestia!e as 'oth a ,eneralied strate,y o+ racial and national +ormation$ and as a somewhat idiosyncratic %ersion o+ the ideolo,y o+ white su&remacy. y +ocus on the anti-hinese &olitical mo%ement and its relationshi& to the racial understandin,s and nationalist &ro!ects o+ the Sonoran re%olutionary +raction who laid the +oundations o+ eicos national state$ ,o%ernin,  &arty$ cultural institutions and nationalist ideolo,y durin, the 1920s and 19#0s$ has led 1 <or recent reassessment o+ the role o+ race in the construction o+ mesti+a)e% national identities and state +ormation in 7atin /merica$ see +or eam&le >el, /. (199?) ur @i,ht+ul Share. The /+ro-u'an Stru,,le +or ABuality$ 166C-1912. ha&el >ill: The ni%ersity o+ orth arolina PressD <errer /. (1999) "nsur,ent u'a: @ace$ ation and @e%olution$ 16C6-1696. ha&el >ill: ni%ersity o+ orth arolina PressD randin . (2000) The ;lood o+ uatemala. / >istory o+ @ace and ation. Eurham: Eu3e ni%ersity Press.D de la adena . (2000) "ndi,enous estios. The Politics o+ @ace and ulture in uco$ Peru$ 1919-1991. Eurham: Eu3e ni%ersity Press. <or the .S. as a racial dictatorshi& see mi . F Ginant (1994:C?-C9). Po&ularied in the nited States in the com&arati%e analysis o+ >arris . (19C4)$ the conce&t was +irst +ormulated 'y <reyre . (H19##I 196C). <or reassessment and criticism o+ this conce&t see Ginant >. (1994) @ethin3in, @ace in ;rail. "n @acial onditions. Politics$ Theory$ om&arisons (1#0-14J). innea&olis: ni%ersity o+ innesota Press.  # me to +ocus more &articularly on the intentioned &olitical de&loyment o+ race as a %ehicle o+ state +ormation. S&eci+ically$ in this article " analye the tra!ectory o+ the anti-hinese mo%ement +rom its ori,ins as a social and &olitical mo%ement to its incor&oration and o++icialiation within the new orthodoy o+ the &ost-re%olutionary state. " am &articularly concerned with understandin, the rele%ance o+ anti-hinese racism and ideolo,y +or the resolution o+ the he,emonic stru,,le 'etween the two dominant Sonoran caudillos: /l%aro 're,Kn and Plutarco AlLas alles. Secondly$ " +ocus on the im&ortance o+ anti-hinese ideolo,y and actions +or the creation o+ consent in the 8unsta'le eBuili'rium that sha&ed eican  &olitics 'etween 1926 and 19#4 (ordo%a 199?). <inally$ " eamine the e&istemolo,ical com&ati'ility 'etween anti-hinese ideolo,y$ the 8cultural re%olution o+ eicos &ost-re%olutionary re,imes$ and the racial understandin,s and sentiments o+ the mestia!e theories in+ormin, eican re%olutionary nationalism. " su,,est that a reconsideration o+ race o++ers a &articular &ers&ecti%e +or the 'etter theoretical understandin, o+ eican state +ormation and the cultural &rocesses throu,h which social identities ta3e +orm in interaction with the state$ its institutions and discourses. The treatment o+ race as a  &olitical &ro'lem also contri'utes to a 'etter understandin, o+ the mechanisms and  &rocesses that trans+orm di++use racial sentiments$ &erce&tions and e&ectations into militant and &olitically or,anied racial mo%ements. Revolutionary disorder, !eno$ho%ia and $o$ular anti-Chinese racism <or the &ositi%ists who dominated intellectual and &olitical li+e durin, the more than three decades o+ President Por+irio Eias authoritarian re,ime (16J4-1911)$ +orei,n immi,ration was seen as the &anacea insurin, Micos social &ro,ress and economic de%elo&ment. n the one hand$ it was 'elie%ed that +orei,n immi,rants would 'rin, with them the ca&ital$ material resources and 3now-how reBuired to e&loit the countrys  4 natural resources. n the other hand$ (northern Auro&ean) immi,rants would su&&osedly  'e more ca&a'le$ resource+ul and hard wor3in, than the 'ac3ward and de,enerated indi,enous la'orers. This elite eno+ilia --a eican term +or lo%e o+ the +orei,n5  'rou,ht two$ contradictory$ res&onses: "n di&lomatic and &olitical terms$ the Por+iran state ,ranted ecessi%e &ri%ile,es and concessions to +orei,n in%estors. n the ,round$ howe%er$ the &o&ular classes in those re,ions where +orei,ners would &resuma'ly immi,rate e&ressed a'horrence and scorn o+ their new +orei,n nei,h'ors. Their eno&ho'ia was &artially shared 'y the middle class o&&osition who ar,ued that Por+irian concessions to +orei,ners were ,ained at the e&ense o+ the ri,hts o+ eican nationals. These sentiments$ which 'uilt on an esta'lished tradition o+ anti-S&anish +eelin,$ +ueled resentments towards the Por+iriatos two lar,est ,rou&s o+ immi,rants: the hinese and .S. /mericans. Ghereas hostility towards nited States citiens was ,rounded$ +or the most &art$ in economic$ cultural and class +actors$ anti-hinese sentiments -- 3nown  &o&ularly as antichinismo -- were o+ten o%ertly racial (onale a%arro$ 19J4:?J-?9). 2 These two currents o+ an emer,ent eno&ho'ic nationalism were o&enly e&ressed durin, the twenty tur'ulent years o+ insurrection and re%olutionary disorder that +ollowed the +all o+ Por+irio Eia in une 1911. #  Throu,hout this &eriod$ /mericans and /merican &ro&erty were +a%orite tar,ets due to their social and &olitical mar,inality$ economic dominance$ and +reBuently a'usi%e and arro,ant 'eha%ior. The more socially inte,rated S&anish also su++ered attac3s on their &ersons$ 'usinesses and &ro&erties. + 2  See$ onale a%arro (19J4$ 1994)$ =ni,ht (196J) and onathan ;rown (196#) <orei,n and ati%e-;orn Gor3ers in Por+irian eico. /merican >istorical @e%iew %ol. 96$ JC6-616. #  These two decades o+ re%olutionary disorder were &unctuated in the +irst &lace 'y the so-called constitucionalista   insurrection that +ollowin, the assassination o+ &resident <rancisco adero in /&ril 191# resisted the counterre%olutionary re,ime led 'y the &or+irista ,eneral Victoriano >uerta. "n the second  &lace 'y the ci%il war 'etween re%olutionary +ractions that etended +rom the de+eat o+ >uerta in mid 1914 to the %ictorious 1920 re'ellion o+ /,ua Prieta led 'y the Sonoran re%olutionaries. nder the military leadershi& o+ /l%aro 're,Kn the Sonoran +orces or,anied in the A!ercito del oroeste &layed a &i%otal role in the %ictory a,ainst Por+irian reaction and in the consolidation o+ the constitucionalista   re,ime led 'y Venustiano arrana. 're,Kn also led the constitucionalista army that de+eated the more &o&ular and radical +orces led 'y <rancisco Villa (Ei%ision del orte  : and Amiliano Na&ata (A!ercito del Sur). <or analysis$ assessment and discussion o+ the nature and conseBuences o+ the eican @e%olution see$ illy (19J1) and =ni,ht (196C). <or the role o+ the Sonorans in the re%olution see /,uilar amLn 19JJ).  ? all the +orei,n ,rou&s$ howe%er$ /ra's and hinese were the most +reBuently attac3ed. "ndeed$ these two ,rou&s su++ered &ro&ortionately more casualties durin, the years o+ re%olutionary %iolence than either S&aniards or orth /mericans. 4  Oeno&ho'ic %iolence also %aried 'y re,ion. /ttac3s a,ainst 'oth orth /mericans and hinese were more serious and +reBuent in Sonora and the other northern states where a ma!ority o+ their in%estments and &o&ulations were concentrated. "n these  'order re,ions$ S citiens and cor&orations were harassed and made to &ay 8re%olutionary taes. "n addition$ they were su'!ected to li%estoc3 the+t$ destruction o+ +ences$ &ayroll the+t$ &ro&erty lootin, and endemic la'or &ro'lems. Still others--es&ecially those who either resisted such treatment or reacted with arro,ance--were 3illed. ?  ;eyond ,eneratin, a ,ood deal o+ tension and con+lict$ these actions had little lastin, e++ect on either the actual &resence o+ orth /mericans in Sonora or ,o%ernment  &olicies towards them. Eurin, the administration o+ the onstitucionalist &resident Venustiano arrana (1914-1920)$ +or eam&le$ ,o%ernment actions a,ainst S owned  'usinesses were limited to issues concernin, la'or relations. o%ernment decrees attem&ted to remedy the a'uses$ e&loitation and discrimination to which S  'usinessmen and +oremen su'!ected eican wor3ers. "n no case$ howe%er$ did they ha%e the e++ect o+ Buestionin, the im&erialist character o+ S &resence in the country. C   4  ;etween 1910 and 1919$ ??0 /mericans$ 4J1 hinese$ 209 S&aniards and 111 /ra's were murdered$ +i,ures that re&resented 2.CC$ #.2?$ 0.6? and J.2? o+ their res&ecti%e &o&ulations. The 1910 o++icial census recorded 1$?#1 /ra's$ 1#$20# hinese$ 24$409 S&anish and 20$C## /mericans. onQle a%arro . (19J4: J4-6C). See also =ni,ht /. (196C: %ol. 1: 44$ 1?0$ 2J9)$ and Turner <. (19C6:2?9-#22). ?  The 1910 national census recorded +or Sonora: 4$46C hinese$ #$1C4 /mericans$ 2?9 S&anish and 16# ermans. The total num'er o+ hinese in eico was 1#$20#. /+ter Sonora the lar,est hinese  &o&ulations were concentrated in Mico ity with 1$462 indi%iduals$ hihuahua with 1$#2?$ Rucatan with 6J? and Sinaloa with CCJ. "ncludin, undocumented indi%iduals not re,istered the total num'er o+ hinese in Mico reached a&&roimately 1?$000. "n 192J the Secretaria de o'ernaciKn re,istered 24$216 hinese esta'lished in Mico. "ts ,eo,ra&hical distri'ution di++ered ,reatly +rom the 1910 &attern.. The de%elo&ment o+ cotton &roduction and the Sonoran anti-hinese cam&ai,ns in+luenced the increase o+ the hinese &o&ulation in ;a!a ali+ornia that 'etween 1910 and 192J e&anded +rom ?#2 to ?$669. Sonora +ollowed it with #$J?6$ Sinaloa with 2$019$ hia&as with 1$2C?$ Mico ity with 1$C02 and hihuahua with 1$0#J. >u-de>art A.(196?:19J-201). <or attac3s a,ainst /mericans see =ni,ht /. (196C$ %ol.1: C6-J0$ J9-60$ 1?6-1C2$ #42-#44) and =ni,ht (196J: ?#-J0). C  See onsular @e&orts in ational /rchi%es -- @ecords o+ the Ee&artment o+ State @elatin, to the "nternal
Related Documents
View more
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks