Sheet Music


Review of Aaron B Retish. Russia’s Peasants in Revolution and Civil War. Citizenship, Identity, and the Creation of the Soviet State, 1914–1922

Review of Aaron B Retish. Russia’s Peasants in Revolution and Civil War. Citizenship, Identity, and the Creation of the Soviet State, 1914–1922
of 3
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
  Aaron B. Retish,  Russia’s Peasants in Revolution and Civil War: Citizenship,  Identity, and the Creation of the Soviet State, 1914-19 . Cambridge, Cambridge University Press, 2008. ISBN: !8"0"#2$"8%8"&.'his ambitio(s boo) *rovides a ne+ yn-h*in or st(dies o the revo(tionary *eriod and o R(ssia/s r(ra *o*(ation. Its )ey -ontrib(tions to the ied are irsty, a re"-on-e*t(aiation o the *robem o *easant nationa identity and the  *easantry1s reationshi* to the state se-ondy, a reassessment o the revo(tionary transormation to in-(de the +hoe *eriod $$&"$22 thirdy, e3*anding the geogra*hi- s-o*e o st(dy o revo(tionary *ro-esses and inay, an integration o the history o *easant revo(tion in R(ssian into the -onte3ts o *easant st(dies ese+here. Retish/s +or) dra+s on an im*ressive so(r-e base, dra+ing on 4irov/s regiona ar-hives aongside -entra ar-hives in R(ssia and the States, ne+s*a*ers and  *eriodi-as, and the most re-ent iterat(re in R(ssian and 5ngish 6is enth(siasm to engage +ith inter"dis-i*inary and -om*arative a**roa-hes is notabe, and sets him a*art rom the oten myo*i- a**roa-h o other s*e-iaists in the ied. 6is -ose reading o o-a so(r-es enabes him to *ersonaise, -om*i-ate and e3*ain day to day *easant reationshi*s and *oiti-s.'he *rovin-e o 7iat)a *rovides the geogra*hi- o-(s or this st(dy. Retish/s introd(-tion does a great ob o giving the reader a sense o the *arti-(arities o 7iat)a and its *eo*e. A n(mber o a-tors disting(ished 7iat)a rom the more -ommony st(died Ba-) 5arth region. Ninety *er-ent o the *easants in 7iat)a had  been eman-i*ated as state *easants in $8%%, +hi-h meant that they had never abo(redor a andord, (iing their obigations in -ash or +ith goods. 'heir neighbo(rs in the Ba-) 5arth regions, most o +hom had been the *ro*erty o *rivate ando+ners  beore eman-i*ation, s(ered rom and h(nger, and dee* resentments estered  be-a(se the *rivate andords tended to retain the best and or themseves ater eman-i*ation. 7iat)a/s *easants did not as a +hoe s(er rom the and h(nger that -hara-terised the Ba-) 5arth regions, and did not have the andord ig(re on +hi-h to -on-entrate resentment. 7iat)a/s *easants +ere o(t+ard bo(nd and o(t+ard oo)ing even beore the 9irst ord ar, as more than ninety *er-ent o ho(sehods inthe *rovin-e reied on non"and based *easant handi-rats and o(t"migrant abo(r to s(**ement their in-omes. 'hese regiona s*e-ii-ities are a starting *oint or Retish/s )ey arg(ment, that 7iat)a/s *easants e3*erien-ed the revo(tionary *eriod o $$&"$22 as a deveo*ment and intensii-ation o their intera-tion +ith the nationa *oity  and their +iingness to (tiise the state as arbitrators o their daiy ives. 'his is an im*ortant de*art(re rom the drit o earier historiogra*hy on R(ssia/s *easants. 'he boo) is organised -hronoogi-ay, +ith -ha*ters -overing the 9irst ord ar, revo(tion, Soviet *o+er, and the Civi ar. Cha*ter $, on the 9irst ord ar,  *resents a detaied eva(ation o the sometimes -oni-ting res*onses o 7iat)a/s  *easants to the +ar eort. ;i)e <osh(a Sanborn and others, Retish arg(es that the +ar  *rovided a or(m or the deveo*ment o nationaist identities and as*irations or in-(sion in the state *oity. 6e dra+s o(t the -ontradi-tory +ays in +hi-h -(t(ra eites de*i-ted the region/s non"R(ssian *eo*es =Udm(rt, >ari and 'atars?, as +ithin the nationa str(gge b(t o(tside the *arameters o nationa -itiens. Cha*ters 2 and @ ta-)e the t(m(t(o(s events o $$!. Retish arg(es that *easants so(ght to be a-tive -itiens +ithin the Provisiona overnment/s ne+ regime, b(t in-reasingy -ashed +ith r(ra eites over ho+ their *arti-i*ation in the state +as to be ramed. Cha*ter & oo)s at *easants/ res*onse to the Boshevi)s/ and de-ree o $$8, and arg(es that the *easantry so(ght to invove the state in -oni-t reso(tion. Cha*ter # e3*ores the three +ay -oni-t that deveo*ed bet+een Boshevi)s, anti"Boshevi)s and *easants in the eary -ivi +ar *eriod, -rystaising aro(nd the iss(es o miitary -ons-ri*tion and grain *ro-(rement. Cha*ter % des-ribes the state/s attem*ts to entren-h itse in the -o(ntryside, thro(gh the deveo*ment o r(ra instit(tions and aian-es +ith the  *easant *o*(ation. Cha*ter ! indi-ates a degree o s(--ess in these state eorts, sho+ing ho+ *easant ang(age and identity be-ame in-reasingy Soviet/ oo+ing state C(t(ra 5nightenment and *ro*aganda -am*aigns. Cha*ter 8 (nders-ores the devastation o the -ivi +ar *eriod, +ith amine, o*en revot and mass migration, b(t arg(es that the state eorts to aeviate amine *rovided (rther o(ndations or an a-tive reationshi* bet+een 7iat)a/s *easantry and the state. An overar-hing theme o his +or) is *easant agen-y and rationaity. Retish st(dies R(ssia/s r(ra *o*(ation as s(be-ts in their o+n right, rather than the *assive obe-ts as *ortrayed in the more dated historiogra*hy. Retish dra+s o(t *easant -on-e*tions o themseves as -itiens, and s)i(y brings together the *eriods o the 9irst ord ar, revo(tion and -ivi +ar. 7iat)a/s *easants diered rom those o their eo+ *easants in other, more st(died regions o the Ba-) 5arth, -entra region and U)raine, and Retish arg(es -onvin-ingy that 7iat)a/s *easants +ere not -on-erned *rimariy +ith and and reedom/ that is, -ontro o and and -om*ete  a(tonomy in their daiy governan-e. P(tting these od historiogra*hi-a obsessions to one side enabes Retish to sho+ that 7iat)a/s *easants +ere a-tive *arti-i*ants in a =sometimes one sided? diaog(e +ith the state and its agents. Peasants +ere a-tive andrationa agents in their oten dii-(t *oiti-a and *ersona negotiations thro(gh the t(m(t(o(s years o +ar and revo(tion. Atho(gh some so-ia and -(t(ra str(-t(res end(red thro(gh revo(tion and +ar, viage attit(des to+ards the nationa *oity +ere (ndamentay transormed in the *eriod. Retish arg(es that *easants +anted to  *arti-i*ate in State b(iding, and that the yo(ng Soviet state gave them that o**ort(nity. 'hro(gho(t, Retish *a-es 7iat)a/s *easantry in an internationa -onte3t, and dra+s attention to ethni- and gender s*e-ii-ities o e3*erien-e. 7iat)a/s Udm(rt and >ari *o*(ations are sensitivey treated. 'he boo) is -eary and (-idy +ritten, and in-(des a n(mber o i(minating i(strations and tabes. A ma* sho+ing 7iat)a/s *osition +ithin the R(ssian 5m*ire +o(d have he*ed ess s*e-iaist readers -onte3t(aise the s*a-e dis-(ssed. Retish/s  boo) +i be re(ired reading or s(be-t s*e-iaists and (ndergrad(ate reading ists,  b(t +i aso be a va(abe -om*arative *oint or s-hoars o *easant -omm(nities in other -onte3ts. Sarah Bad-o-)  !niversity of "ottin#ha$
Related Documents
View more
Related Search
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks